Water for Elephants is a novel told from alternate perspectives (both past and present) by the same protagonist, Jacob Jankowski. In the present, Jacob is a 90-something year old man living in a nursing home. He is isolated and bored, without any real enthusiasm or purpose in his life. He states in the first chapter: “I used to think I preferred getting old to the alternative, but now I’m not sure. Sometimes the monotony of bingo and sing-alongs and ancient dusty people parked in the hallway in wheelchairs makes me long for death” (13). The news of the arrival of a travelling circus however, causes the ghosts of Jacob’s past to reappear and throws his mundane routine into a tailspin. Jacob as a younger man was an integral part of a circus, and it slowly comes to light as the novel progresses, that Jacob has kept a secret for many years about a murder that occurred during his years in the circus. For the entirety of the novel, Jacob slips in and out of reality, detailing both his past and present life in rotating chapters. It is only at the very end of Water for Elephants that the secret surrounding the murder is revealed.
Although the basis of the novel sounds intriguing and mysterious, Sara Gruen does not deliver a novel that contains either of these qualities. The secret that Jacob Jankowski has kept hidden for decades is essentially a disappointment. Reading the novel, the secret of the murder becomes obscured and insignificant in the unfolding of the storyline; there is no suspenseful build up to the big secret reveal at the end of the novel (and to be perfectly honest, I even forgot that there was a secret to begin with). Creating cliffhangers is clearly not one of Ms. Gruen’s strong suits. I do have to say however, that although Sara Gruen has not mastered the art of mystery, she exemplifies masterful writing in the chapters told from the perspective of Jacob as an aging man in a nursing home. Gruen has created a unique, relatable and completely human protagonist in Jacob as a 90 year old man. Jacob instills compassion in readers; he also possesses wit and depth. Just one example of this can be seen on pages 7-8 when Jacob declares: “This being Friday, we’re having the usual nutritious but uninteresting combination of meat loaf, creamed corn, reconstituted mashed potatoes, and gravy that may have been waved over a piece of beef at some point in its life. And they wonder why I lose weight…I know some of us don’t have teeth, but I do, and I want pot roast…I want corn on the cob. Sometimes I think that if I had to choose between an ear of corn or making love to a woman, I’d choose the corn…sometimes I substitute an apple for the corn.”
Although elderly Jacob is honest, sincere and made of flesh and bones, Jacob as a young man does not possess any of these stellar attributes. Contrary to his older persona, the young Jacob is extraordinarily superficial. It’s true that young Jacob falls in love, and cares for and protects animals throughout the novel, yet despite these actions, Jacob remains aloof. A prime example of Jacob’s emotional distance from readers occurs at the very beginning of Water for Elephants. Within the first pages of the novel, Jacob’s parents die in a terrible accident, leaving him utterly alone in the world. The deaths of Jacob’s parents start a chain of events that essentially lead Jacob to run away and inadvertently join a circus. The tragic and sudden deaths of both of Jacob’s parents do not have any resounding impact on Jacob. Their deaths are not even mentioned after the second chapter of the novel. Death is not a significant, life altering, heartbreaking event in Water for Elephants; its impact does not reverberate throughout the rest of the novel. It almost seems as if the younger Jacob is impervious to death.
My last BIG fault with Water for Elephants is the repetition of the prologue WORD FOR WORD in an ending chapter in the novel (Chapter twenty-two to be more specific). In an attempt (I’m assuming) to create some type of cohesiveness to the tale, Sara Gruen places the prologue exposition at both the beginning and the end of the novel. Placed at the beginning of Water for Elephants, the prologue essentially becomes the substratum for the rest of the novel by establishing the mystery of the murder. However, by repeating the prologue at the end of the novel (I mean come on! You can’t even bother to tell it from a different perspective?), Sara Gruen demonstrates her complete lack of originality. It appears as if at the end of 300 pages, Ms. Gruen simply got tired of writing. (This repetition really irked me to no end).
Overall, Water for Elephants is a fast read based on an interesting concept (…I mean, it’s not being transformed into a major motion picture for nothing). However, there are many flaws within the novel that I just can’t look beyond! Thus, in my book review, it earns only a 12.5 out of 20. The more detailed system breakdown follows:
Total Points Awarded:
12.5
Point Breakdown 101:
Category 1: Theme
A. Consistent and clear theme(s)
B. Fully developed and explored theme(s)
-Tie into plot and character development
C. Thought invoking theme(s)
Total Points Received in this Category: 1
***Points Lost: Did not meet requirement B or C
Category 2: Characters
A. Characters are unique
B. Characters are animated and relatable (3 dimensional)
C. Characters possess human characteristics and depth
D. Character learns something about self or world; Experiences a moment of clarity/ revelation
E. Characters seek to enhance plot and themes
Total Points Received in this Category: 3.5
***Points Lost: Received .5 on requirements A, B, and C
Category 3: Plot
A. Beginning, middle and end (although not necessarily in that order)
-Organized structure (interrelation of all parts of a story to make a whole; completeness)
B. Cohesive, thoughtful design to story telling
C. Meaningful, significant purpose (what aim to reveal, criticize, or showcase)
-Clarity, thoughtfulness and relevance of detail to enhance purpose
D. Presence of a struggle /conflict/ trial/ adversity
E. Interesting/ attention holding
F. Satisfying Conclusion
-Brings together Plot, Theme, Character in a succinct and satisfactory manner
Total Points Received in this Category: 5
***Points Lost: Did not meet requirement F
Category 4: Style
A. Writing style is accessible to readers (not elevated language)
B. Style accurately communicates themes and enhances character representations
C. Contains consistency in expression, execution and design of ideas
D. Illuminates rather than obscures basic human truths
E. Effectively helps to create a complete reality
F. Effectively communicates human emotion with unique and powerful language
Total Points Received in this Category: 3
***Points Lost: Received .5 on requirements D and E; did not meet requirements B or F
Caitlin’s Overall Opinion of the Book:
This is a fast and easy read. Water for Elephants is enjoyable although it is hard to really connect on a more than superficial level with the majority of the main characters. It would not be the first book that I would pick off a bookshelf, but it also wouldn’t be the last.
No comments:
Post a Comment